ROME — Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi of Italy won a budget vote in
Parliament on Tuesday but the tally showed that he no longer has the support of
the majority, a huge humiliation that raised the pressure on him to resign in
the face of an escalating debt crisis that has hobbled Greece,
threatens Italy and could infect the rest of Europe.
The budget vote came hours after Umberto
Bossi, a key ally in Mr. Berlusconi’s center-right coalition, publicly asked
him to step aside for the sake of the country, the euro zone’s third-largest
economy and a new epicenter of a crisis that has raised investor anxiety in
markets around the world.
Mr. Bossi asked the prime minister to
relinquish his post in favor of Angelino Alfano, the secretary of Mr.
Berlusconi’s Peoples of Liberty Party.
Mr. Berlusconi’s coalition received 308 votes
in favor of passing the bill, but 321 lawmakers did not vote — a clear sign
that “Mr. Berlusconi no longer has a majority,” said Pier Luigi Bersani, the
leader of the opposition Democratic Party. He also called on the prime minister
to immediately hand in his resignation to President Giorgio Napolitano.
“Let the president find a solution, we will do
our part,” Mr. Bersani said.
Expressing alarm about Italy ’s rapidly rising
borrowing costs, a reflection of investor fears over the country’s economic
future, he said: “We all know that Italy runs the real risk of
not being able to access the financial markets in the next few days.”
The vote came after yields on 10-year Italian
government bonds — the price demanded by investors to loan Italy money — approached 7
percent, the highest levels since the adoption of the single euro currency 10
years ago and a far cry from the 0.3 percent that Germany pays.
Mr. Berlusconi had said earlier that he would
decide his political future based on the outcome of the vote, a routine
verification of the 2010 budget. The vote had taken on immense political
importance for the prime minister after the defection in recent days of a
number of lawmakers in his party.
Still, by late afternoon, Mr. Berlusconi had
given no indication what course of action he was preparing to take.
The prime minister had reiterated repeatedly
in recent days that the coalition must stick together to pass a series of
austerity measures that will placate the financial markets that have targeted
Italy’s financial vulnerabilities, just as they have done in Greece, the euro
zone’s other crisis-ridden member. No less than the future of the euro and Europe is at risk, Mr.
Berlusconi has said, playing on a national sense of responsibility to rein in
his detractors.
But critics countered that Mr. Berlusconi was
among the chief reasons for the financial attacks on Italy . The scandal-plagued
prime minister, who is on trial for corruption, tax fraud and paying for sex
with a minor, has worn away what had been left of his international credibility,
they say. And after months of parliamentary deadlock, Mr. Berlusconi has shown
that he does not have the political backing to push through the measures that
are required of Italy to remedy its
financial ills.
Last month, Mr. Berlusconi pledged to the
European Union that he would approve a new round of restructuring, including
the privatization of state assets, liberalizations of the labor market and a
modest pension change, but his promises did little to quell market anxieties.
Even the decision taken at the Group of 20
Summit last week to allow the International Monetary Fund to monitor Italy ’s implementation of
the pledged reforms did little to bolster investor confidence.
Opposition parties had said they would abstain
from the vote on the budget, which meant that Mr. Berlusconi did not need to
reach an absolute majority to pass the measure. But even so, the numbers were
closely watched to see whether Mr. Berlusconi could muster a healthy majority
that would ensure at least a measure of stability in the short run.
President Giorgio Napolitano, who is
constitutionally required to manage a political crisis, has a number of options
open to him.
Mr. Berlusconi and his coalition allies are
pressing for new elections, though recent polls indicate that they would not
win the numbers to return to power.
Some opposition leaders, numerically empowered
by the poll predictions, are also tempted by a return to the polls 18 months
ahead of the scheduled end of the legislature.
But neither the current majority or any of the
opposition parties are likely to garner a solid majority on their own, and it
is probable that a multiparty coalition with conflicting vested interests would
not have the political cohesion necessary to pass unpopular measures.
Another option is to appoint a technocrat —
Mario Monti, a former European commissioner, is commonly mentioned — as head of
the government for a fixed period of time that would allow for reforms to be
enacted.
Despite the crisis, it remains to be seen
whether a government led by someone like Mr. Monti would actually come up with
the unity to govern.
The country’s political crisis has been
exacerbated by coalition partners in both the majority and the opposition that
are openly hostile to Europe, remaining “at the margin of the European
political network,” and making it more difficult to push through reforms
demanded by Europe, said Sergio Fabbrini, director of the School of Government
at Luiss University in Rome. In this situation, a changeover in government is
unlikely to make much of a difference, he said.

No comments:
Post a Comment